How to Keep Emails Out of Spam: Why I Cleaned My List (And What Happened to My Open Rates)
If you are wondering how to keep emails out of spam, you are definitely not alone. I recently used the new Flodesk Deliverability Center to fix this exact issue for my own business, and the results completely blew me away.
Quick Answer: The fastest way to improve your open rates and stay out of the spam folder is to regularly clean your list and authenticate your domain. Removing unengaged subscribers signals to inbox providers that people actually want to read your content, which will immediately boost your deliverability and get your emails seen.
For years, I bought the email marketing courses, attended the live workshops, and listened to the experts. Time and time again, I was told that an open rate of 25% was amazing—the absolute GOLD STANDARD. I was told that as my email list grew into the tens of thousands, my open rate would naturally drop, and I shouldn’t worry about it.
So, I didn’t worry about it. But over time, I noticed a frustrating trend. People who had actively signed up to receive my homemade room recipes and printable labels were sending me DMs on Instagram saying they never got them.
There I would be, right in the middle of cooking dinner or helping my daughter with her homework, having to stop everything, log into my computer, and manually resend the printable. It was frustrating for my readers and exhausting for me.
I knew I needed to clean my list and keep my subscribers warm, but I was terrified of deleting hard-earned subscribers or breaking something technical.
That all changed when Flodesk launched the new Flodesk Deliverability Center. Here is the exact walkthrough of what I did, the real screenshots from my account, and the staggering numbers I saw when I finally cleaned my list.

This post contains some affiliate links, including partnership with Flodesk. Thank you for your support, read the full disclosure policy.
What is domain authentication?
SPF, DKIM, and DMARC prove to inbox providers that you are who you say you are. In plain English, these technical records verify your sending identity, protect your domain from scammers, and signal to email services like Gmail and Yahoo that your messages are safe to deliver.
To be honest, domain authentication always sounded a little intimidating to me—maybe you feel the same? Thankfully, domain authentication was already in Flodesk, but the brand-new Flodesk Deliverability Center adds context and clear next steps that finally make it easy. So if you’ve haven’t done this yet, here’s how:
- Open the Domain Authentication tab in Flodesk.
- Follow the Compliance Checklist.
- Simply copy the codes Flodesk provided and paste them into my domain host.
Instead of leaving you to figure out confusing acronyms, this checklist walks you step-by-step through setting up each record. So you can watch the warnings turn into green checkmarks.
My email deliverability rate now consistently hovers at an incredible 99% and my emails marked as spam dropped to absolute zero, as you can see in the following screenshots.

How often should I clean my email list?
You should clean your email list every three to six months to keep your subscribers warm and your open rates high. Consistent cleaning ensures you are only sending messages to people who actively engage with your content, which protects your sender reputation.
Once I confirmed my domain was verified—which is actually where I began, since I had already verified my domain, I clicked over to the Audience Health tab. This tab gives you a visual breakdown of your subscribers, dividing them into four clear categories: Healthy, Drifting, At-Risk, and Unengaged.
Seeing exactly how many people on my list were completely unengaged made it so obvious why my emails were landing in the spam folder. If a large chunk of your list is ignoring you too, inbox providers notice, and they start filtering you out. That is when I headed straight to the List Cleaning tab.
You May Also Like
Learn how to design emails that feel like you with a designer-built email studio.
What happens when you clean your email list?
List cleaning moves unengaged subscribers out of your active list so they no longer count toward your sending metrics. Read this carefully: nobody is deleted.
This detail is the only reason I finally took action. I work incredibly hard to create my cozy living guides, printables, and the content that I share, so the idea of permanently deleting a subscriber felt terrible. Learning that Flodesk simply archives them gave me the peace of mind to actually move forward—and I hope it does for you too.
Plus, you can undo it at any time if you realize you made a mistake or want to restore a contact.
Which list cleaning level should I choose?
You can choose between three levels of cleaning, depending on how aggressively you want to remove inactive readers.
- Light scrub: Archives unengaged subscribers only.
- Standard clean: Archives unengaged and at-risk subscribers.
- Deep clean: Archives unengaged, at-risk, and drifting subscribers.
Because this is the first time I was cleaning my list in years—I decided to start with a light scrub. Flodesk automatically identified the exact unengaged subscribers who were dragging my metrics down. I hit confirm, and those inactive readers were safely archived.
What happened to my open rates after cleaning my list?
After cleaning my list, my open rates jumped from 10.4% all the way up to 56.9% over the course of a single month. Because I was no longer sending emails to inactive accounts, my overall email engagement skyrocketed and my emails completely stopped landing in spam.
The progression was absolutely incredible to watch.
Here’s What Happened
- Right before my light scrub, my open rate was sitting at a dismal 10.4%.
- Immediately after the clean-up, I was still hesitant and worried I might not be doing the right thing—but my next email bumped up to 13.1%, so I decided to stay with it.
- One week later, my open rate hit 38%, and I was astounded.
- The week after that, it climbed to 48.7%. I have no words.
- And now, a month later, my open rate is a staggering 56.9%.
If you want to do the exact same thing for your list and finally get your open rates up, Join Flodesk and try the Deliverability Center for yourself!

How do you know if you need list warming?
After cleaning your list, Flodesk recommends that you begin list warming, and it provides a simple checklist right inside the Deliverability Center to help you decide how to move forward. If you are unsure if you need it, start with this self-check questionnaire inside the List Warming tab:
Check What Applies To Your Brand
If you check even one of those boxes, warming could help. And Flodesk gives you a button to start the process right there!
How do you warm up an email list?
To warm up an email list, you gradually send emails to small, highly engaged segments before rolling out broadcasts to your entire audience. In Flodesk, warming segments start at 50 subscribers, allowing you to gradually rebuild trust with inbox providers.
You see, I don’t know about you, but I assumed list warming meant emailing cold, unengaged subscribers to wake them up. Turns out, it is actually the exact opposite! You want to send to your most recent and engaged subscribers first so that inbox providers see strong engagement immediately.
Here are the four steps Flodesk walks you through to warm your list:

Step 1: Clean your list
Archive subscribers who stopped engaging so every warming email goes to someone likely to open it.
Step 2: Create warming segments:
Flodesk automatically splits your list into segments, starting with your most engaged readers.

Step 3: Write one engaging email
Write something that reminds the subscriber why they signed up. You will send this same email to each segment in turn.
Step 4: Schedule emails at the suggested cadence
You can choose a cadence of As fast as possible, Once a week, or Every two weeks.

Flodesk even gives you a “Recommended warming plan” box that dynamically calculates exactly when your warming will be finished based on your start date. I am planning to run a full list warming sequence using the Once a week cadence in January to kick off the new year with perfect inbox placement!
How can you grow your email list without paying more?
When you are consistently cleaning your list and focusing on deliverability, you want an email marketing platform that grows with you without penalizing you for your success. As a proud Flodesk Partner, I love that they support you without raising the cost of service while growing a healthy, active audience!
That’s because Flodesk’s Unlimited Plans are back, with unlimited subscribers and unlimited emails for one flat price. Plans start at $38 a month, billed annually. Whether you have 5,000 highly active readers or 50,000, you never have to worry about jumping into a new, expensive pricing tier just because your deliverability strategies are working.
On top of that, even if you tried a Flodesk trial in the past, they have opened it up again so you can test out a free trial of the unlimited plan now!
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Why did my email open rates suddenly drop?
A: Oftentimes, open rates drop because you have too many unengaged subscribers on your active list or because your domain lacks proper authentication. When either of these happen, inbox providers start routing your emails to the spam and promotions folder.
Q: Does cleaning my list delete my subscribers?
A: No. Inside the Flodesk Deliverability Center, cleaning your email list does not delete your subscribers. List cleaning simply moves unengaged subscribers out of your active list to protect your deliverability. Nobody is deleted, and you can undo it at any time.
Q: What are the Flodesk list cleaning levels?
A: The Flodesk list cleaning levels are light scrub, standard clean, and deep clean. A light scrub removes only unengaged subscribers, a standard clean removes unengaged and at-risk subscribers, and a deep clean aggressively filters out anyone who hasn’t engaged recently.
Q: How do you warm up an email list?
A: You warm up an email list by sending campaigns to small, highly engaged segments of your audience first. In Flodesk, warming segments start at 50 subscribers, allowing you to gradually rebuild trust with inbox providers before sending to your entire list.

Find this helpful?
Share it on Pinterest
And while you’re there, be sure to follow Life-n-Reflection for more inspiring ideas.
What is one email habit I should copy this week?
The best habit you can start this week is checking your Audience Health tab at the end of every month. Getting a regular baseline of your engagement prevents deliverability issues before they start, saving you from sudden drops in open rates.
If you do nothing else this week, log into your account, open the Flodesk Deliverability Center, and take two minutes to check your audience health—it will tell you right away what your next best move should be.
